TL;DR — Skool vs Udemy for brewers
Quick verdict: Skool wins for brewers who care about community feel, gamification, and a flat price. Udemy wins for brewers who need deep course delivery, custom branding, or a specific feature Skool does not ship. Most brewers land on Skool.
Pricing — what each actually costs
Skool: flat $99/mo per community, plus Stripe fees. Udemy: varies — usually tiered by member count or features. For brewers with 50–500 members, Skool is almost always cheaper. Above 1000 members, the math gets closer.
Where each one wins for brewers
Skool wins on: gamification (levels, leaderboards), simple course classroom, mobile app feel, low pricing complexity. Udemy wins on: customisation, specific features Skool lacks, sometimes deeper LMS, sometimes better course delivery. The honest answer for most brewers: pick Skool unless you have a specific feature need Udemy fills uniquely.
What both lack
Neither Skool nor Udemy ships real DM automation, churn-saver, comment-mining, or member tagging out of the box. tools4skool is the layer most brewers bolt on regardless of which side they pick — it works on Skool today and we plan to expand to other platforms.
Verdict for brewers
If you do not have a strong reason to pick Udemy, default to Skool. The community feel and gamification will get you to 100 paying members faster than Udemy will. Add tools4skool around member 50 to plug the automation gap.
Try Skool free for 14 days.
See the platform for yourself before committing. No card required.
The infra above runs on tools4skool.
DM sequences, churn saver, comment miner, exports — the layer skool.com does not ship.
Book a demo →Frequently asked
Is Skool worth it for brewers?
For brewers with at least 20 paying members, almost always yes. Skool collapses what used to be a Discord plus Kajabi plus newsletter stack into one tool, and the gamification keeps members showing up. Below 20 members the $99/mo flat plan is hard to justify; above 50 it usually pays for itself many times over.
How much does Skool cost for brewers?
$99 per month per community, flat — Skool does not charge per member. Stripe processing adds 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction. So 100 members at $49/mo = $4,900 collected, $99 to Skool, ~$165 to Stripe, ~$4,636 take-home before any other tools.
What is the biggest risk for a brewers on Skool?
Churn. Skool ships zero churn-recovery tooling — when a member cancels you find out at the end of the month, by which point they have moved on. Most brewers bleed 10–25% of revenue annually to silent cancels that a 60-second save-DM would have caught.
Can I migrate from Facebook groups or Discord?
Yes — bulk-invite via email is the cleanest path. Export your member list (most groups let you), then send a one-time invite from inside Skool. Expect 30–50% to follow you in week one if your audience is engaged.
Do I need an extension like tools4skool?
Not at first. Once you cross ~50 paying members, manual DMs and ad-hoc spreadsheets stop scaling. tools4skool fires welcome DMs, churn-saver DMs, and lets you tag and segment members — the layer Skool itself does not ship.
What is the fastest way to grow as a brewers?
Pick one offer (course, coaching, or community), get the first 25 paying members from your existing audience, then double down on whatever channel got them — usually one platform: YouTube, IG, or LinkedIn. Skool is the destination, not the discovery channel.